News 4 min read

UK tribunal forces government to admit secret Apple encryption order


The UK’s Investigatory Powers Tribunal ruled on November 19, 2026 that the government can no longer refuse to say whether it served Apple a technical capability notice, the secret order it reportedly used to demand access to encrypted iCloud data. Privacy International, which brought the case with Liberty and two individuals, says the ruling confirms Apple has been served with one. The ruling strips away the government’s “neither confirm nor deny” line on an order of a kind that can require any tech company to keep the ability to hand over its users’ data.

What’s new

The open judgment in Apple Inc v Home Secretary and others ([2026] UKIPTrib 9) was given by Lady Carmichael, the tribunal’s president, with Mr Justice Chamberlain and Mr Justice Johnson. According to Privacy International’s summary:

  • The secrecy claim failed. The government argued that confirming or denying any notice would harm national security. The tribunal found it gave no detailed evidence of that harm.
  • The government had already undercut its own policy. The tribunal noted that officials had acknowledged the notice to reporters and to the US government, which weakened their reliance on “neither confirm nor deny”.
  • What the order contains is still secret. The ruling covers only whether the notice can be acknowledged. Reuters, reporting on the ruling, says the tribunal found the government “has not established that it would be damaging to national security to reveal” the notice, and that how much of its detail comes out will be decided at later hearings.

The trial on whether the notices are lawful at all is not expected until next year, Reuters says. Apple’s own challenge, filed in July 2026, is being case-managed alongside the Privacy International and Liberty claim.

“Today’s judgment is a major victory for transparency and effective oversight,” said Caroline Wilson Palow, Privacy International’s legal director.

How we got here

When What happened
February 2025 Reports say the Home Office served Apple a notice covering iCloud data protected by Advanced Data Protection (ADP).
February 21, 2025 Apple stops offering ADP in the UK to new users.
September 2025 The first notice, which Reuters says covered US and UK users’ backups, is reportedly dropped after talks with the Trump administration.
October 2025 The Financial Times reports a second notice that covers only Apple’s UK customers; Apple’s first appeal is dismissed over a “change in circumstances”.
July 2026 Apple files a new challenge to the Home Secretary’s power to issue these notices.
November 19, 2026 The tribunal rules that the notice can be acknowledged.

What it means for developers

A technical capability notice is issued under the UK’s Investigatory Powers Act. It doesn’t hand over data by itself. It requires a company to keep the technical ability to provide data when a warrant later asks for it, and the company isn’t allowed to say it has received one. Until this ruling, a firm in Apple’s position couldn’t even confirm the order existed. The tribunal’s reasoning makes that harder to keep up once the government itself has talked about an order.

For anyone building on iCloud or shipping apps to UK users, today’s facts are these:

  • ADP is still unavailable to new UK accounts. Apple’s support note says UK users who hadn’t already turned on Advanced Data Protection can’t enable it. The 15 iCloud data categories Apple encrypts end to end by default, plus iMessage and FaceTime, aren’t affected.
  • If your app stores sensitive data in a user’s iCloud account (CloudKit, iCloud Drive, backups), assume UK users don’t have ADP. Apps that need end-to-end protection there have to encrypt on the device with keys the server never sees, rather than relying on the platform setting.
  • Watch the next hearings. The tribunal will decide later how much of the notice is disclosed, and the trial will test whether such orders can force a company to weaken encryption at all. The outcome matters to any company with UK users, not just Apple.

If your app also calls Apple’s on-device and cloud AI, the other Apple change to plan for this month is the daily limits on Siri AI and Apple Foundation Models in iOS 27.3.

Sources